Malverne, tucked away in the southwestern corner of the Town of Hempstead, is a culinary treasure trove often overshadowed by its flashier neighbors. Yet for foodies in the know, this quaint village offers a mouthwatering mix of classic comfort, beloved bakeries, and surprise finds. Whether you’re strolling along Hempstead Avenue, grabbing a casual bite before a summer concert on Church Street, or seeking a quiet brunch oasis, Malverne’s food scene makes everyone feel at home. Here’s your definitive guide to eating your way around Malverne, from buzzy hotspots to hidden gems only locals whisper about.
Classic Eats & Local Institutions
The heart of Malverne’s food scene revolves around tried-and-true favorites where locals have gathered for decades.
Connolly Station (280 Hempstead Ave)
Step inside this Irish pub just steps from the Malverne LIRR station and you’ll feel right at home. Connolly Station serves up generous portions of shepherd’s pie, corned beef and cabbage, and classic burgers—all at wallet-friendly prices ($10-$22 entrees). The draft beer selection, friendly staff, and lively trivia nights keep things bustling. Locals swear by the fish and chips and the weekend brunch, which offers a hearty full Irish breakfast.
Malverne Delicatessen (356 Hempstead Ave)
Just down the block, Malverne Deli is an institution for quick breakfasts and satisfying lunches. Their egg sandwiches on house-made rolls, overstuffed deli heroes, and daily soups have fueled generations of Malverne residents. Sit outside in warmer months, or grab your breakfast to go—the sausage, egg, and cheese with hot sauce is legendary.
Cozy Cafés & Sweet Spots
Whether you’re starting your morning or winding down your afternoon, Malverne’s inviting cafés and bakeries are all about good vibes and great tastes.
Crossroads Café (312 Hempstead Ave)
A true neighborhood gem with exposed brick walls and local art, Crossroads Café is beloved for its rich espresso, croissant breakfast sandwiches, and cozy atmosphere. Their rotating menu of pastries—from pecan sticky buns to vegan scones—draws a loyal morning crowd. Prices are affordable ($3-$12), and the staff greets regulars by name. Don’t miss their seasonal lattes and homemade muffins.
Malverne Pastry Shop (253 Hempstead Ave, near Utterby Rd)
Family-owned for more than 40 years, Malverne Pastry Shop is a nostalgic trip back in time with its glass display cases spilling over with butter cookies, fluffy layer cakes, and fresh-baked Danish. Pick up a box of their signature rainbow cookies or the decadent blackout cake for birthdays and celebrations. Reasonably priced and always busy around the holidays, this bakery is a sweet cornerstone of the community.
Surprising Global Flavors
Malverne’s food scene shines with global flavors—and a few unexpected discoveries for adventurous eaters.
Umberto’s of Malverne (345 Hempstead Ave)
Craving classic Italian? Umberto’s delivers with its legendary brick-oven pizzas, pillowy garlic knots, and robust pasta dishes. The arancini and chicken scarpello are favorites, with entrees ranging from $14-$28. The red-sauce charm, white-tablecloth service, and menu specials make this perfect for date night or family dinner alike.
Sangria 71 (1095 Jericho Turnpike, just over the border but worth the ride)
Just outside Malverne proper, Sangria 71 brings the vibrant flavors of Spain to the neighborhood. Dive into sizzling gambas al ajillo (garlic shrimp), hearty paellas, and of course, fruity pitchers of sangria. The rustic décor and lively tapas menu ($10-$26) make this a go-to for group gatherings and long, laughter-filled evenings.
Best Bets for Casual Bites
Sometimes all you need is a fast, flavorful meal—Malverne delivers here, too.
Joe’s Pizza & Pasta (319 Hempstead Ave)
Beloved by families and students, Joe’s offers quick slices, big salads, and Italian comfort food staples. Their crispy-edged grandma pie is a Malverne must. Order the garlic knots and a large pie for a classic New York pizza night—expect to pay $3-$5 for slices and $15-$25 for full pies.
Gino’s Pizza (164 Hempstead Ave)
Gino’s is another fan favorite for melt-in-your-mouth mozzarella sticks, piping hot heroes, and creative specialty pies. The “Gino’s Special” white pizza never disappoints. Prices hover around $4 for a gourmet slice and $20 for specialty pies.
Food Trucks, Fairs & Local Traditions
Malverne’s food traditions spill out onto the streets with food trucks, outdoor festivals, and community gatherings.
During the annual *Malverne Street Fair* each fall, food trucks and vendors line Church Street and Reese Place with everything from Korean BBQ skewers to cannoli, fresh lemonade, and funnel cake. Local organizations often host bake sales outside Malverne Community Church, while the village’s summer concerts bring ice cream trucks and popcorn carts right onto the village green. For a true local tradition, grab soft serve from the neighborhood Mr. Softee truck as the band plays.
Hidden Gems & Neighborhood Secrets
Some of Malverne’s most memorable meals are hiding in plain sight—here’s where in-the-know locals go.
Il Villaggio (120 Woodfield Rd)
Just outside the village core, Il Villaggio is the kind of Italian restaurant people whisper about—white tablecloths, vintage ambiance, and an impressively curated wine list. The seafood risotto and veal marsala shine, and the desserts (especially the tiramisu) are house-made perfection. Perfect for anniversaries or a splurge meal ($20-$38 entrees).
La Estrella De Oro (396 Hempstead Ave)
This tiny, family-run Mexican spot is often missed by visitors, but loved by locals for its authentic tacos, homemade salsa, and friendly pricing. Carnitas tacos and the stewed chicken burrito are menu standouts. Most dishes come in well under $15.
Where to Start Your Food Adventure
Start with a walk up and down Hempstead Avenue between Franklin Avenue and Woodfield Road, or around Church Street for easy access to most of Malverne’s culinary hotspots. Whether you’re hunting for classic pizza, fresh pastry, surprising ethnic flavors, or simply somewhere to savor a good cup of coffee, Malverne rewards the curious—and hungry—visitor.
So next time you’re nearby, skip the chain restaurants and let yourself be charmed by Malverne’s cozy, creative, and always-satisfying food scene. One meal here, and you’ll be planning your next foodie tour before the check arrives.